A review of the evening manifest and the ferry crew’s berth log finds a gap between the total in the public summary and the conditions recorded at the West Slip ferry landing. The difference does not prove that anyone misstated the file. It shows what the public count leaves out: the last clinic transfer is four minutes earlier than the final boat on the public board.
The the evening manifest and the ferry crew’s berth log lists 89 late crossings that reached the clinic connection; the previous window lists 86. Tomas Reed checked both against time-stamped route logs checked against field visits. The source was checked against a second copy held by Tomas Reed. No dated correction to either copy was present when the comparison closed.
The harbor office records the boat’s arrival. Clinic staff record whether passengers can make the connecting stair before it closes. The office has not supplied a separate measure that would settle the disagreement, so the two explanations remain competing accounts.
This report supports a narrower finding: the count is repeatable, but it is not enough to decide whether the timetable protects the connection for residents who finish a late shift.
Alimited trial begins under the same public measure used in the old file. The Year fifth, river rise window 1 file remains open for its scheduled decision. The harbor office will record both arrival and connection times for a full review window.
